I am confused, and worried about the future of the library. In a matter of hours, I am told that I need to look elsewhere for a full-time job, and then in the same day there seems to be enough evidence that will compel me to stick to my career. There are so many mixed signals that I am getting, that I am unsure of where all this is headed. Sometimes I have to help patrons who are angry because of accruing fines on their accounts, and they sometimes tell me they won’t be coming back. On the other hand, I get patrons who tell me they will always want a physical book to read. It seems more frequently that even children are spending less time reading and more time on their phones or other devices, and teens are doing the same. A lot of patrons are in the library just to use the patron computers. Children and teens are two age groups are very important to reach in public library programming. The article Reading is In Decline: If Not You, Then Who? by Paula Wilson was written not very long ago, in 2017. Wilson (2017) states,
Only 51 percent of
children said they love or like reading books for fun, compared to 58 percent
in 2012 and 60 percent in 2010, and reading enjoyment declines sharply after
age eight, according to Scholastic’s The
State of Kids & Reading [3] (1).
If we cannot reach these demographics, I picture a
domino effect for the rest of the programming in public libraries, for certain.
In the technology age, it seems like the public library is
overcome with technology, and a lot of the patrons are using e-books and Audible
more than they frequent the actual library building. Plus, the nightmare of the
Retail Apocalypse is not comforting, either. While there are the usual clothing
stores like Macy's and others that are closing its doors, so are bookstores. Borders
was among the first to close, and now people are predicting that Barnes and Noble
may not be far behind. The New Yorker published an article labeled What Barnes and Noble Doesn’t Get About
Bookstores, by David Sax (2018), states,
The key question for
Riggio now is figuring out what purpose Barnes & Noble serves today. Amazon
dominates the industry with low prices and a vast selection and is even
flirting with brick-and-mortar bookstores, having opened two in the past year.
Independent bookstores—once assumed to be on their way to extinction—own the
romantic notion of a bookstore as a place, like a church or a social club,
where communities are nurtured. Barnes & Noble is stuck in the middle, a
giant saddled with hundreds of huge stores, and an image of corporate sameness
in a market that has increasingly come to treasure defiantly independent
bookstores (1).
With the rise of audiobooks sellers such as Audible,
and e-books, and general lack of funding, who is not to suggest that libraries
are at risk of closure, too? One would think that, if patrons were angry enough
about fines, they would just buy books at Barnes and Noble instead.
A third area of concern for me is that library schools
seem to be graduating a lot of librarians. This is fantastic, and I am happy
that there is still an interest and always like meeting new friends and colleagues
in my classes, but, from what I could see, there aren’t enough full-time jobs
to go around, and the library job market is highly competitive. How do I set
myself apart from the rest of the librarians who are wanting the same job as
me? How do I get my foot in the door? How do I gain experience in a position
that requires leadership, but the volunteer opportunities that are available do
not provide chances to gain leadership skills? Most importantly, how do I prove
that my age does not reflect my skill set or experience level?
If anyone could disprove my concerns, and shed some light
on them, I would be happy and completely grateful. I do know being in libraries
is exactly where I need to be. To quote The Hunger Games by Suzanne
Collins, I just hope that “the odds will be forever in my favor” for finding a
full-time job when I graduate!
Works Cited
Sax,
D. (2016). What Barnes and Noble Doesn’t
Get About Bookstores. Retrieved from https://www.newyorker.com/business/currency/what-barnes-noble-doesnt-get-about-bookstores.
Wilson,
P. (2017). Reading Is in Decline: If Not
You, Then Who?. Retrieved from http://publiclibrariesonline.org/2017/01/reading-is-in-decline-if-not-you-then-who/.
I agree with getting the mixed signals. As one of the older people getting into the world of libraries, I hope that my age doesn't put off the people doing hiring. I know it shouldn't, but I think it might. And I get the question why are you studying to be a librarian, the libraries are just going to close up anyway because nobody reads books like they use to because of electronics. I feel your concerns.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Mary! I'm sorry you are feeling the same way, but I'm glad I'm not the only one thinking/feeling that, at the same time. I am definitely going to stick with being in libraries, and I am very passionate about books and literature in general, and I love my job and classes. I'm just nervous about the future of it all.
DeleteI think your concerns about children not loving reading, proved by the statistics, are very real! Often at my library, we would have kids who had parents that would get cards for them when they were very young, and then check out their own things on it. This ruined the child's card and would cause massive fines before the child could even read independently. Then, when they were actually interested in books, they couldn't check them out and lost interest quickly. To get around this, my library began offering Youth cards that had a limit of five books or audiobooks, but have no late fees. Kids can get one even if their original account is in poor standing. This has been huge for us in terms of getting books into the hands of interested kids- I love that you mention Summer Reading as well, because that's also a big one for us! So, I think things can be done to help kids get their interest back, and lots of it lies is making sure things are extremely accessible. That may include outreach too and bringing books directly to them.
ReplyDeleteI like your library's policy on children's cards! That's a great idea! It is sad how the parents sometimes ruin reading for children when they haven't even really started yet. I heard a while ago that one patron used reading as a punishment. It should never, ever be considered a punishment to read! It should be enjoyable for everyone. You are so right about making books accessible, too!
DeleteThose statistics you cite from Scholastic are troubling. However, the massive amount of books we put into people's hands everyday (that there would be almost no way for them to afford otherwise) seems to reflect the incredible efficiency and efficacy of a centralized information source supported by public funds. This holds true for physical books, e-materials, etc. Even if these numbers are declining I regularly see families walk out with 30 plus children's books not to mention the digital materials they are accessing because the library subscribes to them. This seems to me to depict the incredible value of what we do and support libraries' longevity.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Craig! You definitely brought up a great point!
DeleteI hope the odds are in your favor! Best of luck and full points on a great post!
ReplyDelete